Hamas – Dead End Street?

As the ceasefire begins and the IDF withdraws from Gaza, consider the following declarations (not verbatim) made by Hamas leaders in recent years:

Ahmed Yassin (leader of Hamas, assassinated by Israel), 1997: “Hamas is ready for a 30-year hudna (truce) with Israel”.

 

Mahmud Al-Zahar (co-founder of Hamas), 2006: “Hamas is offering a full hudna for the long term, if a Palestinian state is erected along the 1967 borders”.

 

Ismail Haniyeh, prime minister of Hamas, 2006: “Hamas accepts the principles of the Arab peace initiative” (which talks about peace with Israel if a Palestinian state is erected along the 1967 borders).

 

Khaled Mashal, leader of Hamas, 2010: “Israel is a fact”. In 2014: “Hamas wants peace, but peace with no occupation and no settlement”.

 

Hassan Yossuf, Hamas leader in the West Bank, 2014: “Hamas is willing to sign a hudna with Israel and accept a peace deal if most Palestinians are in favour of this”.

As Israel mourns dozens of its sons killed in the last round of fighting in Gaza; as yet another “operation” ends inconclusively; as Gazans bury hundreds and contemplate the destruction around them – perhaps it is time for Israel’s government to pause and rethink its years-long policy of “managing” the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

This policy assumes the current status quo can continue indefinitely, with no need for peace talks with the other side (because the assumption is “there is no partner”). Perhaps it is time to realize that no matter how strong the IDF is, this is a conflict that will never be solved by military force alone. The fact is that after 4 weeks of ferocious assault, Hamas is still launching rockets into Israel. The same happened in the Second Lebanon War (2006), where after a month of Israeli onslaught Hezbollah continued to rain rockets on northern Israel.

For many years, Israel did not speak with the PLO. In fact, it was a felony for an Israeli citizen to meet someone from the PLO. And yet today Israel’s wettest dream is for Gaza to become like the West Bank! Israel has already talked with Hamas and reached agreements: the freeing of kidnapped soldier Gilad Shalit and the ceasefire in 2012. So declaring “we don’t talk with Hamas” is an empty declaration.

Forget peace. That’s not the goal. Let’s aim lower for now: a long-term period of silence. To achieve this, Israel needs to combine its military response to terrorist groups like Hamas with an ongoing effort to reach an understanding with its neighbours. As prime minister Netanyahu himself pointed out, the circumstances created by this latest round of fighting might just result in the formation of new alliances in the region, leading to a stabler future. Let’s hope this opportunity is not squandered.

Advertisements

One thought on “Hamas – Dead End Street?

  1. Hi,

    I discovered your review on Amazon. I have a book that I think may be of interest to you, and I would like to send it to you. I am seeking an honest review of the item that I send.
    The name of the book: The Hamas Independnce War: How Israel Become Hostage Of Hamas – Gaza War 2014
    How did Hamas cause the collapse of Israel’s deterrence strategy? What lead to war in Gaza in 2014?
    This text contains revolutionary and innovative information revealing how Hamas has managed to take advantage of the military and civilian capabilities to lift the siege.
    It will give in-depth answers to complex questions, such as:
    Why won’t Israel enter Gaza?
    What strategies has Israel taken to influence Hamas to end the war in Gaza, and why have these strategies failed?
    Why didn’t the Iron Dome change the rules of the game?
    My name is Nir Segev, an MA from the University of Haifa and expert in Israeli-Palestinian conflict, presents an alternative perspective on the war in Gaza and argues that each situation will leave Hamas with the upper hand in the realization of the main goal: establishing a strong country, both economically and militarily.

    There the link for the book:
    http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00N40SFEG

    Thanks you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s